Genes do not carry memory
The main disadvantage of the film, of course, is in absolute unscientific nature, although it is presented as a true science fiction film. Here you will find both robots and aircraft almost on nuclear fuel, spaceships, aliens, etc.
The main blunder is that the hero Tom Cruise, being a clone of a rocket pilot flying to an alien ship, would never have remembered his wife who fell to the ground in a rescue ship. Because genes do not carry information about who a person lives with, what shops they go to, and what they do in life. That is, memory is located exclusively in the brain. And even if they will be thousands of clones, the brain still develops individually and as a result it can be absolutely not similar people. And it would be very dangerous for people to record some events from the past life for aliens, and there can be no such way of writing to the brain purely from human biology.
Then the second, the protagonist is well controlled with weapons apparently fighting for a long time with scavengers, was it really not interesting to remove their helmets, see what kind of creatures. Jack anyway, of course, otherwise there would be no film.
Then, why should aliens contain any people at all, if they themselves are at a very high level of technology, these robots could be repaired by other robots, and their others.
On the main ship of aliens, a bunch of these flying crap, why was it necessary to repair them at all, with such weapons to destroy all the people on the planet would be no difficulty, if the local population prevents them from collecting water.
There are many such mistakes that turn the plot into a fairy tale.
As a plus, it can be noted that the Americans managed to escape from anthropomorphic newcomers, and indeed aliens who resemble something that already exists on the ground - calmar, cockroaches and other creatures. Here it seems to be a completely civilization of aliens of non-biological origin. This is interesting, but the topic is not disclosed at all, and the second part does not seem to be.
Well, and with the quality of the effects, the graphics here are no problems. If you turn off the head, everything looks interesting and exciting. As a movie attraction quite fit.
Комментарии
Отправить комментарий